How to Build A Lean System of Organizational Learning

The world of corporate training and development has yet to fully embrace the new reality of technology, online resources, and the need to integrate learning into the daily habits of all managers and team members. This requires a map of the learning process, eliminating waste, and breaking down silos.

Just as colleges and universities are struggling to confront out-of-control costs and the integration of new technology, corporate training and development must also adopt a new paradigm to deliver competence and capabilities to their customers.

Corporate Training Expenditures Soar

Forbes Magazine just completed their annual research on corporate training. Last year spending increased 15% to $70 Billion in the US and $130 Billion worldwide. The number one area of spending is on management and leadership development – 35%. That equals $24.5 Billion in the  US and $45.5 Billion worldwide for management and leadership development training.

Why? Forbes stated:

“All our research on corporate talent shows that global leadership gaps continue to be the most pressing issues on the minds of business and HR leaders. As Millennials take on more responsibility, companies need to build leadership skills at all levels and in all geographies around the world.”

From Forbes 2/02/2015

From Forbes 2/02/2015

Two other significant findings by Forbes: High performing companies spend more and “technology is revolutionizing this market.”

“The research shows an explosive growth in technology tools to train people today. Self-authored video, online communication channels, virtual learning, and MOOCs (Coursera, Udacity, Udemy, edX, …) are all growing rapidly as training tools. People still need formal classroom education, but this is now less than half the total “hours” people consume in training around the world. And among the highly advanced companies, as much as 18% of all training is now delivered through mobile devices.”

The New World of Training and Development

So, what is the problem? The problem is that much of these expenditures are anything but “lean.” Specifically:

  • Many corporate trainers, internal and external, are wedded to the old model – “Send them to me and I will talk and they will do exercises, we’ll have great coffee breaks, go home, and it is their problem what happens after that. I’ve done my job!” In other words, it is “silo-ed” and lacking a continuous process flow that begins with a defined need and ends in proof of performance.
  • Leaders send subordinates to training and expect them to be “fixed,” with little acceptance of responsibility for coaching and observing demonstrated competence in a defined skill.
  • Learners go to training or watch online courses with little understanding that they are responsible for performing, demonstrating competence, and adding value. This is  not their fault. It is the fault of the system – the absence of accountability and consequences.

The solution is a system that creates value and returns the investment, which must include the following elements:

  • Line managers must define, with the help of training professionals, competency-based training that builds specific skills that will then be used and coached on the job.
  • Participation in online learning, whether through internal learning management systems or MOOC’s like Udemy, should not simply be a do-it-yourself “go watch this and learn something” model. On the contrary, courses should be watched on the individual’s time, but an entire team of managers should participate together, with an internal coach facilitating the application of learning in the real world environment. Learning comes from doing, not watching!!
  • It is a new, but old, paradigm. Learning must be managed and not left to chance. Each manager must be responsible (that means held accountable) for the development of her people. They must be given a system of learning for which they can be responsible.

“Institute a vigorous program of education and self-improvement.” Dr. Deming’s 13th point.

A  System of Organizational Learning

Let me suggest how a “lean” learning system might work. The purpose of this model is to both incorporate the efficiency of online learning technology while at the same time understanding that learning occurs through applied action, iterative experimentation, coaching (feedback) and consequences to behavior.

Learning System

 Antecedents

Organization leadership has the responsibility to establish the conditions for purposeful learning. These include the following:

  • A Strategic Capability Model that Defines Cultural Competencies: Where are we going, why, and what capabilities do we need to get there? Organizational learning is not an act of personal fulfillment. It must be made purposeful by a strategic model that defines the capabilities, technical and social, that the organization must possess to succeed in the future.
  • Leadership Responsibility: Just as each unit of the business is held accountable for budget items, achieving targets of productivity or sales, the same business unit leaders must  be equally responsible for building the  human capabilities that will lead to the fulfillment of strategy.
  • Structure and Systems: To establish a system of learning, the structure, systems and tools must be put in place by leadership. The online learning system needs to be established or purchased. The structure of internal coaches who will follow up and counsel managers on their application of lessons learned in online programs is essential to the process.

 The Action-Learning Process

If you were told that you were being sent to a three day workshop on how to play the guitar, and after that you were expected to perform before an audience and win their applause, you would rightly consider that a very bad idea! But, that is how much our training dollars are spent. Action learning is entirely different, and it is the natural way one learns any skill: a little knowledge – a little practice – a little feedback and reflection – then more advanced knowledge, practice, etc. And, all the practice is performed in the natural work setting of the learner.

This diagram will look somewhat familiar to all who have employed the Plan-Do-Check-Act cycle, and it is similar in its iterative learning and experimentation process. However, it is adapted specifically to management and leadership development.

 Learning System21. Learn: Acquire Knowledge

In traditional learning  models this is where most of the time, attention and costs went. No longer. This is the easy part. This is where online learning changes everything. To use my own course as an example, the individual can learn the problem solving models, process management, the skill of developing scoreboards, solving human performance problems, and facilitation skills while sitting at home in the evening or at Starbucks on their tablet. The knowledge is all there. In the case of my team leadership course, there are 17 hours of lectures broken into 74 separate lectures. It is enough for one full year of management development when combined with the other three elements.

 2. Do: Practice the Behavior

Learning System3To take the example of learning the guitar, as anyone who has tried knows, the essential step in real learning is building the habits through practice. Learning management and leadership skills are no different. Effective communication and facilitation, for example, is a skill comprised of a set of habits. We  know what those habits are. The knowledge is relatively simple. But, developing the habitual behavior of listening well, inquiring sincerely before judging, or acknowledging the contribution of others, is less about  knowledge than habit.

Where does the manager practice these skills? The best place is right where he or she works – in their own work or management team. One might expect this to be uncomfortable. However, if the team is learning together, all trying out new behavior, the performance anxiety is minimized.

3. Study: Coaching & Reflection

Learning System4At Toyota every manager has a coach. Every leader is developed through a period of years by learning, doing and coaching. It is the norm. However, while almost every company is striving to adopt lean manufacturing or culture, few are taking the coaching practice seriously. There is something in our culture that causes us to say “I’m OK, I can do it myself, I don’t need a coach!” Tom Brady has a coach. Peyton Manning has a coach. But, our managers too often think they don’t need one!

Coaching is giving feedback on how you are performing a specific skill. It is not asking the same questions over and over again. It is asking questions about the application of the specific skill you are learning and practicing at that time. A skilled coach follows a learning path in support of the acquisition of knowledge, and the sequence of practice. As an example, I have defined a sequence of activities and related coaching questions that follow my Team Leadership course.

4. Act: To Reinforce Habits

Learning System5It is the responsibility of leaders to reinforce the learning of those habits and skills that comprise the capabilities that will lead to strategic success. Ultimately, you get what you reward!

It is unfortunate that many leaders do not see the connection between reinforcing those skills for which the organization is providing training, and achieving a return on those training dollars. I can’t tell you how many times I have seen a huge investment in culture change efforts, only to see the promotion of someone who everyone knew had displayed behavior contrary to that which the leaders professed to support. Nothing is more discouraging.

When new management skills are learned by a critical mass of the organization’s members, those management practices become standard work. They should be identified as standard work in fulfillment of a competency model for that job. At that point they become part of the culture.

 Consequences

Ever since my days early days setting up a free economy behind prison walls, I have been a great believer in the power of consequences to influence behavior. The culture of training and development was, for too long, one in which measurement of outcomes, changes in behavior and performance, were not seen as part of the process. Trainers were comfortable in the silo of training departments, and were content to hand-off a trained individual to line management and consider their job complete. This silo must be broken.

  • Measure Cultural Competence: Leadership and management training can demonstrate changes in behavior on the job. I have long had assessments and accountability measures for training in team leadership and lean leadership skills. Those measures include the direct application of the skills to improve operating performance.
  • Leadership Accountability for Modeling Behavior: If you want your managers to practice good process management or problem solving skills, the leaders must model that behavior. Only that modeling will demonstrate its importance and instill the belief that those skills pay-off.
  • Reinforce Demonstrated Performance: Those implementing lean management have largely ducked the issue of reward systems. Why? Rewarding desired behavior gets you more desired behavior. Yes, it can sometimes be complicated or not perfectly “fair.” No reward system is. But, in one Merck plant, for example, as they went through the team leadership training a set of deliverables were identified, and the annual plant bonus, for both salaried and hourly employees, were tied to the completion of those deliverables. It was a strong motivator!

Whether you agree with all of the elements of the system proposed above is not critical. What is critical is that we rethink the system of learning in our organizations to eliminate waste and gain maximum benefit. I believe the above elements will move most organizations in that direction.

New Year’s Wishes – To Be Challenged – Not “Happy”!

I hope you all had a great Christmas, or any Holiday you celebrate. And, I hope you are ready for a wonderful New Year. Not a “happy” New Year, but a New Year filled with great challenges. More about that in a minute. I have been very quiet on this blog for the last several months because my attention has been very focused on the challenge of creating great online learning courses. I first published my Team Kata course this year and I am now breaking that down into more manageable pieces and expanding on the topics that make up the Team Kata. I have published Problem-Solving Made Easy and Learn to Motivate Yourself and Others. Next up are Learn to Facilitate Great Team Meetings, How to Lead Value-Stream Mapping, and From Forming to Performing – The Basics of Team Management. My intention is that together these will form a … Continue reading

Toyota Kata, Team Kata, and Levels of Complexity

Implementing lean management, or any other change in the culture of organizations, requires a zoom lens to see the different levels of complexity required. Toyota Kata, lean tools, and other methods operate at some focal lengths and not at others. The well informed manager will have the ability to understand complexity and to use simple methods when appropriate. If you are photographer with only a 300mm lens you will miss a lot of great photos.

Continue reading

Engaging Everyone in Lean! A Cost Effective Solution

Let’s be honest about lean implementation and training. In most organizations lean training is for a select few. These same few may engage a few more. But, the dominant culture, the dominant habits of working and managing too often do not change.

What if you had an effective method, and a low cost method, of training and engaging everyone in the organization? This is now available through an partnership of Lean Leadership Institute and myself.

Continue reading

The Coaching Kata

I developed my Team Kata Udemy.com training course to provide a solution to training a large number of people, self-paced and over an extended period of time. But, coaching is essential to the learning process. Here are examples of the coaching kata that follow well proven methods of behavior based training.

Continue reading

The Lean System of Motivation

One aspect of lean that has not been given enough attention, in my opinion, is how lean is an organization wide system of motivation that creates a high performance culture. Too many lean implementations suffer from a focus on problem solving skills, but a failure to attend to the system or culture of motivation. Too many rely on the “they oughtta wanna” assumption which usually results in disappointment.

A highly motivated work force is not an accident. It is not the result of being in one part of the country or another, have having a union or non-union. It is the result of systematic efforts on the part of management to design and improve a system of motivation. The most effective systems optimize both an ennobling purpose, the social bonds of strong teamwork, and the availability of individual incentives. They all contribute unique elements to a holistic system of motivation.

Continue reading

New Year’s Wishes for All Leaders – Corporate and Country

Two years ago I published what I thought would be worthy New Year’s resolutions for managers. Below I am both repeating some of those and adding a few new thoughts. I hope they are worthy of your consideration. You might want to challenge your management team to agree on some collective resolutions for the New Year. It may promote a useful dialogue. First, Promote Unity of Thought and Action in the New Year: We live in a world of competition in which false dichotomies are promoted to gain advantage over others. The recent NY Times article on Benghazi, in great detail (for those who have the patience to actually read in-depth research) describes the complexity of militias with competing and changing interests and their varied reactions to American policy that led to the assault. Reality is often confusing and complex so we immediately dump reality into familiar buckets that give … Continue reading